The Attorney General’s office confirmed an open Bureau of Criminal Investigation case involving Sheriff David Hilliard days before the election. A recording shows how he answered when a councilmember accused him of drinking on duty, and what county officials told her afterward.
The state Bureau of Criminal Investigation has an open investigation involving Oliver County Sheriff David Hilliard, the North Dakota Attorney General’s office confirmed to 701 Report on Thursday, five days before he faces voters.
The recording, documents and audio referenced in this story are at the end.
The office would not say what the investigation involves. It is not known what prompted it. The Center Republican first reported the investigation in its Oct. 29 edition.
Separately, a recording obtained by 701 Report shows how Hilliard responded this month when a Center city councilmember, sitting across from him with two county officials in the room, accused him of drinking on duty.
He swore at her. He called her a liar. He said he was going to talk to his lawyer. Then he walked out.
“You are f—ing lying,” Hilliard told Councilmember Brittany Hagen.
Seconds later: “If you want to make that accusation, this meeting is done, because I’m going to go talk to my lawyer.”
Hagen had spent months trying to raise concerns about the sheriff’s office through official channels. After Hilliard left, the two county officials whose jobs come closest to overseeing his office told her there was little they could do.
“As far as Sheriff Dave, my hands are tied,” said Alice Grinsteinner, who handles human resources for the county. “He’s an elected official.”
“Like I tell people, we have an election,” said Commissioner Rob Schmidt. “That’s how you fix stuff.”
Hilliard denied Hagen’s accusation on the recording. He has not responded to questions 701 Report sent him on Oct. 23 and Oct. 28, including a follow-up about the investigation. His office has acted on 701 Report’s records requests during that time: Chief Deputy Jim Wenning wrote that Hilliard directed him to send the requested records, and the office’s administrative staff answered every records email promptly.
Hilliard’s only opponent on the Nov. 3 ballot is his own chief deputy, Jim Wenning, who told 701 Report he is not campaigning against Hilliard but will serve if elected.
Every channel she tried
- Late July: Hagen reported to county human resources that a deputy’s patrol vehicle was sitting at his home for long stretches during times she understood him to be on duty. She reported the dates in writing on July 31.
- Late July: She went to the sheriff’s office to request its duty schedule. She says Hilliard called the office before she finished the form and said she could not have it.
- Aug. 10: Hilliard asked the city council to take away her police portfolio, the council’s oversight role for his office. The mayor did it on the spot, without a vote.
- Oct. 5: After a written warning from the city attorney, the council removed her again, this time by vote. The same night, it scheduled a recall election against her. The recall petition is chaired by Hilliard’s stepson.
- Oct. 14: She met with Hilliard, Alice Grinsteinner of county human resources and Commissioner Rob Schmidt. Hilliard walked out after she accused him of drinking on duty. The officials who stayed said their hands were tied.
- After the meeting: The officials pointed her to the state board that licenses law enforcement officers. She says the filing information she was promised never came.
Hagen’s first story with 701 Report covered how she lost her oversight role. This story is about what happened next.

Asking him to stop
Hagen says she asked for the October meeting as a private citizen, not as a councilmember. She told 701 Report she had heard before the meeting that Hilliard was telling people he planned to sue her.
She said so at the start of the recording, before the sheriff came in.
“I’m going to record this because there were some things said to me that would lead me to believe that somebody is going to try to use me meeting with you guys as a lawsuit against me,” she said. “I’m here more on my own recognizance than anything.”
Her request was simple. “I would like for him to leave my name out of his mouth,” she said.
Part of what she wanted stopped was the recall petition. One of its listed reasons for recalling her is “disrespect and unprofessional conduct towards Oliver County Human Resources Director.” On the recording, Grinsteinner said she had never seen the petition. “I’m sorry my HR was brought in that petition,” she said.
The petition’s chair, Hilliard’s stepson Tanner Schleve, is also the only candidate who has filed to run against Hagen in the Jan. 11 recall election. “The only petition I have to run in that election against Brittany is from Tanner Schleve,” City Auditor Cassie Smith told 701 Report.
The meeting was on Oct. 14. Present were Hagen, her husband Jeremy Hagen, Hilliard, Oliver County Commissioner Rob Schmidt and Alice Grinsteinner, who handles human resources and emergency management for Mercer and Oliver counties.
Hagen is relatively new to Center. On the recording, she described a town quick to turn on people who speak up. “I’ve lived in a lot of small towns. But I’ve never, ever, ever seen anything like this,” she said, describing “the way that they continue to find a way to slander the next person.”
The confrontation
Hilliard’s first question when he arrived was about her husband. “I just want to know why Jeremy is in here,” he said.
“Last time you guys talked at a meeting, you were kind of disrespectful,” Jeremy Hagen answered.
The two went back and forth over the recall petition and who was saying what about whom. Then Hagen made the accusation.
“I have watched you drinking in a bar on duty,” she said.
Hilliard denied it immediately.
“I guarantee you, you have never seen me drink on duty. You are f—ing lying,” he said. “You are a liar. That is not true.”
“I have probably had, like I said, 10 or 12 beers in this city in 30 years, and never have I ever drank in uniform,” he said. “And if you want to make that accusation, this meeting is done, because I’m going to go talk to my lawyer.”
Her husband spoke up. “I seen it the same day she seen it, dude,” Jeremy Hagen said.
“I have never had a drink in uniform,” Hilliard said. “You are lying.”
“So everybody’s lying,” Hagen said.
“This meeting’s done,” Hilliard said, and he left.
After the sheriff walked out, Jeremy Hagen told the officials what he had seen. “I’ve had respect for Dave forever,” he said. “But the day we’ve seen him doing it at the bar, I told her not to say anything.”
Listen: The exchange, as recorded by Hagen. Contains profanity.
Hagen has said she saw Hilliard drinking last winter while he was in uniform and on duty. She has put that account in a signed statement.
701 Report has not independently verified the account. Hilliard denied it on the recording.

“My hands are tied”
Hagen did not take her concerns to just anyone. Schmidt holds the law enforcement portfolio on the county commission, according to the Center Republican. Grinsteinner handles human resources for county employees. They are the two county officials whose jobs come closest to overseeing the sheriff’s office.
An elected sheriff has no boss in county government. After Hilliard left, both officials said as much: Grinsteinner about the sheriff, and Schmidt about his deputy.
Grinsteinner also told Hagen her earlier concerns had already been taken to the sheriff. “When you met with me, I brought your concerns to Dave,” she said. “But then like my hands are tied. Unfortunately.”
Schmidt said the same about the deputy Hagen said had been sending her threatening messages. “My hands are tied on Cale,” he said. “Commissioners can’t touch him.” He said they had “tried on different situations,” adding, “I’ve tried many times.”
Neither official questioned Hagen’s account of seeing the sheriff drinking on duty. Neither said whether they believed it. Instead, Grinsteinner pointed her to the state Peace Officer Standards and Training board, which licenses law enforcement officers and can revoke a license. “Document everything,” Grinsteinner said.
Schmidt’s answer, as he put it, was the election.
Hagen told 701 Report that Grinsteinner was supposed to send her information about filing with the POST board after the meeting. She says it never came.
Listen: After the sheriff left, county officials on what they can do.
Neither Grinsteinner nor Schmidt responded to 701 Report’s questions by the deadline.

A state investigation
The Attorney General’s office confirmed the investigation in a one-line email to 701 Report on Thursday: “BCI does have an open investigation involving the Sheriff.”
Schmidt told the Center Republican the county commission has not received official notification of any investigation. Hilliard told the paper he could not comment because he was unaware of an investigation and did not know what it pertained to.
It is not known whether the investigation is connected to any of the concerns Hagen raised.

The deputy next door
The deputy is Cale Ferderer, Hagen’s next-door neighbor.
In July, Hagen documented several dates when Ferderer’s patrol vehicle sat at his home for long stretches during times she understood him to be on duty, including at least one night when it was left running unattended. She reported the dates to county human resources on July 31.
At the Aug. 10 council meeting, Hilliard described the concern that had been raised: that his deputies “were not doing their work in their full hour, full shift.”
The sheriff’s office requires every deputy to keep a take-home patrol vehicle, so a patrol car parked at a deputy’s home is not unusual on its own. Its policy also says unattended vehicles are to be locked, with keys removed unless the vehicle must be left running.
In September, after Hagen sarcastically thanked Ferderer for signing the recall petition against her, the two traded Facebook messages. Hagen told county officials at the Oct. 14 meeting that she considered his messages threatening. 701 Report has reviewed the exchange.
Ferderer did not respond to questions sent through the sheriff’s office.
No cameras for the sheriff
Records released this week show most of the department works without cameras. Only two patrol vehicles have in-car video and body cameras, according to a letter from Chief Deputy Jim Wenning: his own and Deputy Bryce Hufford’s. Neither the sheriff’s vehicle nor Ferderer’s is equipped.
The office’s own policy says each uniformed deputy is responsible for being equipped with an office-issued recorder before going on duty. Wenning wrote that the equipment is new for the department and is being added as funding allows.
Wenning, who wrote that letter, is also the only other candidate for sheriff on the Nov. 3 ballot.

Records, compared
The sheriff’s office still has not released its deputies’ duty rosters from July and early August, which 701 Report requested last week. The county’s attorney called them exempt and said the decision belongs to the sheriff’s office. When the office did release its camera and vehicle policies this week, Wenning wrote that Hilliard had directed him to send them.
Neighboring agencies split on the same request. The Mercer County Sheriff’s Office, which runs the dispatch center Oliver County uses, released its rosters for the same dates after a short phone call, with deputies’ names redacted. The Morton County Sheriff’s Office declined, saying the records are exempt.
State law allows either choice. In Oliver County, the schedule was also refused to the councilmember the city had assigned to oversee the department.

On the ballot
Wenning got on the ballot through write-in votes in the June primary. In a statement to 701 Report, he said he has chosen not to actively campaign against Hilliard “out of respect for him and his many years of service to Oliver County and its residents.”
“The people of Oliver County put me on the ballot as a write-in candidate for Sheriff in the general election and I will leave it to the people of Oliver County to make the decision of who they want to be their next Sheriff,” he wrote. “If elected by the people of Oliver County, I will accept this position to serve and protect the citizens of this county as Sheriff to the best of my abilities with pride and dedication.”
Asked how overtime is approved and who decides whether past schedules are released, Wenning referred those questions to Hilliard and Grinsteinner.
Who we asked
701 Report sent questions to everyone named in this story and gave each until noon Oct. 29 to respond. Hilliard was also asked about the BCI investigation, with a 5 p.m. deadline.
- Sheriff David Hilliard: asked Oct. 23 and Oct. 28, including about the recording, plus a follow-up about the BCI investigation. Directed his chief deputy to release requested records during the same period. Did not respond.
- Deputy Cale Ferderer: asked Oct. 28 through the sheriff’s office. Did not respond.
- Alice Grinsteinner, county human resources: asked Oct. 28. Did not respond.
- Commissioner Rob Schmidt: asked Oct. 28. Did not respond.
- Chief Deputy Jim Wenning: asked Oct. 28. Responded Oct. 29 with a statement on the race; referred questions about office practices to Hilliard and Grinsteinner.
- Councilmember Becky Berg: asked Oct. 28. Did not respond.
- Councilmember Troy Hatzenbihler: asked Oct. 28. Did not respond.
- Tanner Schleve, recall petition chair: asked Oct. 23. Did not respond.
- Mayor Kevin Hoffman: asked Oct. 23. Did not respond.
- North Dakota Attorney General’s office: asked Oct. 28. Confirmed the BCI investigation Oct. 29; did not say what it involves.
- City Auditor Cassie Smith: asked Oct. 29. Confirmed Schleve is the only candidate who has filed to run against Hagen.
This story will be updated if anyone responds.
What comes next
701 Report has requested dispatch logs for the same weeks Hagen documented, and is waiting on additional records about the sheriff’s office.
The election is Nov. 3. Polls are open 8 a.m. to 7 p.m. at the Oliver County Courthouse, 115 W. Main St., Center.
Documents and audio
Every record behind this story, as 701 Report received it. Personal information has been redacted. The recording was made by Brittany Hagen, a participant in the meeting. Contains profanity.
Audio: The Oct. 14 confrontation (Hagen, Sheriff David Hilliard, Jeremy Hagen)
Audio: After the sheriff left (Alice Grinsteinner and Commissioner Rob Schmidt)
- N.D. Attorney General’s office confirms BCI investigation, Oct. 29, 2026
- Center city auditor confirms recall election candidate, Oct. 30, 2026
- Chief Deputy Jim Wenning’s statement to 701 Report, Oct. 29, 2026
- Morton County Sheriff’s Office denies duty roster request, Oct. 28, 2026
- Mercer County Sheriff’s Office patrol schedules, July and August 2026 (redacted)
- Oliver County Sheriff’s Office letter on cameras and vehicles, Oct. 27, 2026
- Sheriff’s office Policy 422: Portable audio/video recorders
- Sheriff’s office Policy 420: Mobile audio/video
- Sheriff’s office Policy 703: Vehicle use (excerpt)
- Oliver County denial of duty roster request, Oct. 23, 2026
- Recall petition against Councilmember Brittany Hagen, cover page (redacted)
Earlier coverage: Oliver County’s sheriff is on the ballot. Read this before you vote.





Leave a Reply