Oliver County’s sheriff is on the ballot. Read this before you vote.

Oliver County’s sheriff is on the ballot. Read this before you vote.


Update, Oct. 27, 2026: After this story was published, the sheriff’s office sent its camera and vehicle policies, and the county auditor sent the requested pay records. The Records section has been updated.

All documents, auidio and clips referenced in this story are linked at the end.

When Brittany Hagen won a seat on the Center City Council in June, she was given a specific job: serve as the council’s liaison to the Oliver County Sheriff’s Office.

That summer, she raised concerns about the sheriff’s department. At a public council meeting on Aug. 10, Sheriff David Hilliard described the concern: that his deputies “were not doing their work in their full hour, full shift.”

At that same meeting, Hilliard asked the council to take the job away from her. Mayor Kevin Hoffman did it on the spot. There was no vote.

The city attorney later wrote that he could not identify any authority for what the mayor did, and the portfolio went back to her. In October, the council removed Hagen again, this time by a 3-2 vote, and the mayor took the role himself. That night, the council also scheduled a recall election against her. The recall petition is chaired by Hilliard’s stepson, Tanner Schleve. Its first listed reason is “disrespect and conflict with Oliver County Sheriff and Deputies.”

Hilliard is on the ballot Nov. 3. His only challenger, Chief Deputy Jim Wenning, got on the ballot through write-in votes in the June primary. Wenning told the Center Republican he is not campaigning but would accept the job if elected.

701 Report reviewed city minutes, meeting audio and video, and public records to piece together what happened. Here is the record.

Oliver County Sheriff's Office RAM pickup truck with blue emergency lights illuminated in Center, North Dakota. Original photograph by Daniel Lamers for 701 Report.

The job

Center has no police department of its own. It pays the Oliver County Sheriff’s Office to police the city. The city’s October bills included $13,827.10 to the department.

On the council, one member holds the police portfolio. That member is the council’s link to the sheriff’s office. It is the closest thing the city has to oversight of the department it pays.

Hagen was given that portfolio after she was elected in June.

Raising concerns, and losing the job

On Aug. 10, the police portfolio came up at the council meeting. According to the minutes, Hilliard asked that it be reassigned. Hoffman moved it to Councilmember Dean Windhorst.

Audio of the meeting, obtained by 701 Report through a public records request, captures what happened.

Hoffman told the council he “was called last Friday” before the meeting. He said the city’s rules let the mayor assign portfolios. “I have the authority to do that,” he said.

Hagen objected. “I raised some concerns with the sheriff’s department,” she said, “and so now they would like to have me removed because I’ve raised some concerns.”

Hilliard said the concerns had gone around him. “I’m the head of my department,” he said.

Asked what the concern was, he said it was that his deputies “were not doing their work in their full hour, full shift.”

Hagen pushed back. “When somebody has a question that also affects the sheriff, he gets upset and asks for that person to be removed,” she said.

Hoffman gave one reason. “The police commissioner and the sheriff cannot work together,” he said.

“We can work together,” Hagen said.

Hoffman ended it. “I have the power. It’s done. I’m moving on to old business.”

In a written response to the recall petition, Hagen said the reassignment set a dangerous precedent. “When we hold officials to the standards of their jobs, rather than rising to meet those standards, they are allowed to simply request someone they believe will allow them to behave as they wish without any oversight at all,” she wrote.

Center Mayor Hoffman sits at the council meeting table reviewing documents in a turquoise binder while holding a pen. A wooden gavel rests nearby. The photograph was taken during a City Council meeting in Center, North Dakota, by Daniel Lamers for 701 Report.

The correction

The mayor’s move drew a written warning from the city attorney. On Aug. 17, he wrote to Hoffman that he could not identify any authority for a mayor to remove a councilmember from a portfolio alone. He asked Hoffman to point to one in writing if he disagreed. He also advised that Hagen stay in the role while the question was resolved, to limit the city’s potential liability.

Hagen read from the letter at the Oct. 5 council meeting. She said Hoffman never put his reasons in writing, as the letter asked.

At the September meeting, the council discussed the correct way to transfer portfolio assignments, according to the minutes. Hagen said the portfolio was returned to her at that meeting. By Oct. 5 she held it again: that night’s motion was to remove her as police portfolio holder.

Center city counsel meeting. Photo taken and enhanced by Daniel Lamers

The vote

On Oct. 5, the council took a vote. Windhorst moved to remove Hagen as police portfolio holder. Councilmember Becky Berg seconded. Windhorst, Berg and Hoffman voted yes. Hagen and Councilmember Troy Hatzenbihler voted no.

Hagen said the mayor still had not given the community a reason. “You are a leader, and you are expected to give a reason,” she said.

Hoffman said the motion came from the council, not him. “A motion was made and seconded by the board. They have that power,” he said.

Two months earlier, when he removed her on his own, Hoffman had put it differently. “That’s the job of the mayor. I have the authority to do that,” he said on Aug. 10. “I have the power. It’s done.”

By Oct. 5, Hoffman described his Aug. 10 action as “a suggestion.” His only stated reason for removing Hagen is still the one he gave that night: that the police commissioner and the sheriff could not work together. 701 Report asked Hoffman why Hagen was removed and what authority he acted on in August. He did not respond by the deadline.

A second motion put the police portfolio with Hoffman himself until a permanent holder is chosen. It passed on the same 3-2 split.

When Hagen asked for discussion, Hoffman moved on to the budget. “You are using your power to shut me down,” she said.

The October minutes are a draft until the council approves them in November.

The petition's first listed reason.
The recall petition's sponsoring committee, chaired by Tanner Schleve, the sheriff's stepson. Addresses blurred by 701 Report

The recall

The same night, the council set a special election for Jan. 11, 2027, on a petition to recall Hagen.

The petition’s first listed reason is “disrespect and conflict with Oliver County Sheriff and Deputies.” It also accuses her of “slanderous and libelous comments” about the sheriff and deputies.

The petition’s chair is Tanner Schleve, Hilliard’s stepson.

701 Report asked Schleve why he started the petition and whether Hilliard had any role in it. He did not respond by the deadline.

Hagen said a special election would cost the city about $10,000. The council was told at the meeting that the election moves forward only if a candidate qualifies for the ballot against Hagen. Write-ins are not allowed.

Hagen disputes the petition’s claims. “I have been unfairly portrayed and represented in many of these allegations,” she wrote in a response to the petition. One accusation says she sent letters to residents on the council’s behalf. She wrote that she has never sent a letter to any Center resident on behalf of the council.

She also questioned the motive. She wrote that she worried the recall had less to do with her performance than with some people’s unwillingness to work with her on the council.

At the Oct. 5 meeting, before the vote to schedule the election, Hagen addressed Hoffman directly. She said he had continued “to shut me out in front of the community by trying to quiet my voice.”

Entrance to the Oliver County Sheriff's Department inside the Oliver County Courthouse in Center, North Dakota.

Records

The sheriff’s office has kept its deputies’ schedules from the public, including from the official the city assigned to oversee it.

Hagen told 701 Report that in late July, while she held the police portfolio, she went to the sheriff’s office to request its duty schedule. Before she had finished filling out the form, she said, Hilliard called the office and said she could not have it, calling it a security concern. The denial was verbal.

701 Report got the same answer. Last week it asked the sheriff’s office for its deputies’ duty rosters from July 1 to Aug. 10. On Oct. 23, Lawrence King, an attorney responding for the county, denied the request, writing that the records were “exempt and prohibited from disclosure.”

That is not what the law says. The statute he cited makes law enforcement work schedules exempt. It does not prohibit releasing them. Under state law, records that are prohibited from release are called confidential. Exempt records are different: an agency can release them if it chooses. When 701 Report pointed that out and asked the county to release the rosters, King said the decision belongs to the sheriff’s office. The sheriff’s office has not released them.

County Auditor Jaden Schmidt, whose office handles the county’s records requests, told 701 Report in person on Oct. 22 that the requests had been sent to human resources and an attorney. On Oct. 23, King asked her office to process the pay records for Hilliard and one deputy. Schmidt sent them on Oct. 27, after this story was first published, at no charge. They show Hilliard is paid $3,254.56 every two weeks, about $84,600 a year.

The sheriff’s office put a price on its camera and vehicle policies: a flat $10 per item, paid in advance. State law allows records fees only for copies and for time spent locating or redacting records beyond a free first hour. Asked how the flat fee was calculated, the office said only that Hilliard had reiterated the $10 charge. 701 Report paid under protest and may ask the state attorney general’s office to review it. The records arrived Oct. 27, after this story was first published.

They show that most of the department works without cameras. In a letter, Chief Deputy Jim Wenning wrote that only two patrol vehicles have in-car video and body cameras: his own and Deputy Bryce Hufford’s. The sheriff’s vehicle is not one of them. The office’s own policy says each uniformed deputy is responsible for being equipped with an office-issued recorder before going on duty. Wenning wrote that the cameras are new for the department and are being added as funding allows, with a third equipped vehicle expected soon. The office also requires every deputy to keep a take-home patrol vehicle ready to respond at all times.

By contrast, the City of Center produced its meeting minutes and audio within a day, for free.

Side-by-side composite showing Oliver County Sheriff Dave Hilliard in his role as a wrestling coach. In the left image, Hilliard is seated beside a wrestling mat wearing a white jacket, blue jeans, and a baseball cap. In the right image, he stands near a wrestler wearing a dark jacket and jeans. The background has been blurred to emphasize Hilliard and reduce the visibility of students. The images have been digitally enhanced and reconstructed by Daniel Lamers using AI.

A split vote on his coaching job

The council is not the only public body to question Hilliard’s accountability this fall.

Hilliard is also an assistant wrestling coach. On Oct. 14, the Center-Stanton school board voted 3-2 to renew his coaching agreement.

The vote came amid concerns about incidents involving middle school wrestlers at a tournament last season, the Center Republican reported. Hilliard was supervising the group.

Board members Brian Dresser and Laura Bakken voted no. Bakken said her vote was “a matter of accountability and student safety,” according to the Center Republican.

Board president Shiloh Becher voted yes. He said Hilliard has coached about 25 years with no prior incidents. He also acknowledged why others disagreed. “Board members felt like someone should be accountable. If not the coach, who?” Becher said, according to the Center Republican.

Hilliard did not respond to the newspaper’s request for comment.

An AI-generated editorial illustration of Oliver County Sheriff Dave Hilliard. The image depicts Hilliard holding an exaggerated, outdated-looking Taser. Photo by Daniel Lamers

Equipment

In a candidate questionnaire published by the Center Republican, county commission candidate Chris Albers wrote that a recent budget meeting revealed deputies’ tasers were years past expiration. He called it unacceptable and a liability.

At the Oct. 6 county commission meeting, commissioners were shown a 10-year taser replacement package at $8,383 a year. They were told the department had not been maintaining a taser training program.

Why this matters

A sheriff is one of the most powerful officials in any county. He carries a badge and a gun, and he has the power to arrest people. The county can’t fire him. That makes every check on him matter more.

In Center, one of those checks was a councilmember whose job was to keep an eye on the department the city pays to police it. When she raised a concern that deputies were not working their full shifts, the sheriff asked that she be removed. The mayor did it on the spot, without a vote. When the city attorney questioned that, the council removed her again.

Public records are another check. They exist so anyone can see how a public office does its job. So far, the sheriff’s office has kept its deputies’ past schedules from the councilmember assigned to oversee it and from 701 Report. It also charged a fee for its policies that it has not tied to anything state law allows.

Hilliard has not answered questions about any of it, from 701 Report or from the Center Republican.

Holding a sheriff accountable is part of the job, not an attack on him. On Nov. 3, voters decide whether they’re getting that accountability.

There is more to this story. 701 Report’s investigation into the sheriff’s office is just getting started.

What voters still don’t know

As Hilliard asks voters for another term, the public record leaves open questions:

  • What happened to the concern that deputies were not working full shifts? Was it investigated?
  • Why did the mayor remove the council’s oversight member without a vote, and on what authority?
  • Why could the councilmember assigned to oversee the sheriff’s office not get its duty schedule?
  • What were the concerns behind the school board’s split vote on Hilliard’s coaching job?

701 Report put questions on these points to Hilliard and Hoffman on Oct. 23 and asked for responses by 10 a.m. Oct. 26. Neither responded by the deadline. This story will be updated if they respond.

701 Report has filed public records requests about the sheriff’s office and will report what they show.

Polls are open 8 a.m. to 7 p.m. Nov. 3 at the Oliver County Courthouse, 115 W. Main St., Center, according to the county’s election notice.

Meeting audio and video

Unedited clips from the public meetings referenced in this story.

Center City Council, Aug. 10, 2026: the police portfolio exchange

Center City Council, Oct. 5, 2026: the vote to remove Hagen from the police portfolio

Center City Council, Oct. 5, 2026: setting the special election on the recall petition

Oliver County Commission, Oct. 6, 2026: the sheriff’s office taser replacement package

Documents

Daniel Joseph Lamers Headshot North Dakota

Written by Daniel Lamers
Reporter & Founder, 701 Report


Discover more from 701 Report

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


One response to “Oliver County’s sheriff is on the ballot. Read this before you vote.”

  1. […] first story with 701 Report covered how she lost her oversight role. This story is about what happened […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *